Everton faced a disappointing defeat against Brighton and Hove Albion, but the loss wasn’t solely about a collapse. Various underlying mistakes gradually paved the way for the visitors to secure victory.

Initially, Sean Dyche’s team displayed a strong start with aggressive attacking play, almost scoring a goal and hitting the post shortly after. However, individual errors proved detrimental, notably with Idrissa Gana Gueye’s costly mistake and Ashley Young’s red card due to impulsive behavior.

A crucial mistake occurred not from an Everton player but from the VAR officials, who once again created confusion within the system during the early second half.

In the second half, Everton maintained pressure, leading Brighton to make errors at the back. Jack Harrison created opportunities, with Lewis Dunk committing a foul on Dominic Calvert-Lewin in the box, resulting in Everton being awarded a penalty—a rare occurrence for them on the Premier League’s opening day. However, hope was short-lived as VAR overturned the decision due to technical issues with the monitor, sparking controversy.

This incident raises concerns about the role of referees in the game. If VAR judgments override referees without proper review, it questions the purpose of their presence on the field. Perhaps, delegating major decisions solely to VAR could streamline the process, potentially saving resources and avoiding pre-game tension at Goodison Park.

Although this incident stands as an anomaly, it sheds light on the hierarchy within officiating and prompts a closer examination of the decision-making process.

Without confirmation of consultation with a backup monitor, ongoing speculation persists. Referees’ importance dwindles as VAR’s decisive authority over subjective calls is increasingly apparent.