Charlie Mulgrew Defends Maeda and Hatate But Celtic Fans Remain Unconvinced
Former Celtic defender Charlie Mulgrew has backed Daizen Maeda and Reo Hatate amid criticism of their performances, insisting neither player has given up on the title race.
Speaking on Go Radio, Mulgrew pointed to their energetic displays against Motherwell as evidence of their continued commitment. “I don’t think Maeda has given up,” he stated. “He has shown signs. Him and Hatate have shown signs in recent weeks, especially against Motherwell, that they want to fight for this.”
However, Mulgrew’s defence also highlighted deeper concerns about the squad’s overall quality. He acknowledged that Celtic’s defeat to Dundee United was a “bad, bad day” and admitted the current group lacks necessary depth and quality. “Unfortunately, the squad and the strength in depth is not there. The quality isn’t there. Martin O’Neill is going to need to find a way to get that from them.”
While Mulgrew believes the Japan internationals remain committed, supporters have legitimate reasons to question their consistency. One positive performance against Motherwell does not erase months of alarming form from two players expected to lead by example during the run in.
With seven matches remaining and Celtic trailing league leaders Hearts by five points, the margin for error has vanished. Occasional “signs” of wanting to compete will not suffice. O’Neill requires absolute, unwavering dedication and match winning intensity from his established stars week after week.
The coming weeks will provide the ultimate test of whether Maeda and Hatate can deliver the consistency required to salvage Celtic’s season. Until then, the doubts lingering among the Parkhead faithful remain entirely justified.